Are you in Canada? Click here to proceed to the HK Canada website.

For all other locations, click here to continue to the HK US website.

Human Kinetics Logo

Purchase Courses or Access Digital Products

If you are looking to purchase online videos, online courses or to access previously purchased digital products please press continue.

Mare Nostrum Logo

Purchase Print Products or eBooks

Human Kinetics print books and eBooks are now distributed by Mare Nostrum, throughout the UK, Europe, Africa and Middle East, delivered to you from their warehouse. Please visit our new UK website to purchase Human Kinetics printed or eBooks.

Feedback Icon Feedback Get $15 Off


Free shipping for orders over $99

Need to access your Online Course or Ebook?

Feldman Model of Criticism

This is an excerpt from Writing About Dance by Wendy Oliver.

Before you can critique a dance, you must observe it. The process of observation is not necessarily orderly; as you watch the colors, shapes, and movement of a dance, you are mixing the processes of perceiving, thinking, and feeling and are unlikely to have a coherent, all-encompassing statement to make at the moment the dance ends. Art educator Edmund Feldman recognized this problem:

[T]here is a systematic way of acting like a critic, just as there is a systematic way of behaving like a lawyer. For lawyers there is a form for presenting evidence, refutingadversaries, citing precedents, appealing to jurors, and so on. Although art criticism does not have the form of legal debate, it does have form. To do criticism well, consistently, we need a form or system that makes the best use of our knowledge and intelligence and powers of observation. (1987, 471)

Feldman proposed to his visual arts students that criticism include description, analysis, interpretation, and evaluation, which are equally applicable to observing and writing about dance. He suggested that each step is necessary to the ones that follow, and for that reason, they should be undertaken in order. This means that thorough and accurate description is the basis for all other aspects of criticism; judgment and opinion need to be withheld until the end of the process.

Description is a straightforward recounting of what you see and hear. It is focused on the individual elements of a dance rather than on the whole. Analysis, on the other hand, explains how the parts fit together to make the whole. Interpretation involves a personal reading of either the entire work or aspects of it; this is where the critic's imagination is fully involved in finding meaning in the work. Evaluation is your considered judgment of the work, which may be either implicitly or explicitly stated. Using Feldman's model of criticism as modified for dance in figure 4.1, you can examine any dance work in detail and begin to make sense of it.

Writing a dance critique is a process that challenges you to describe, analyze, interpret, and evaluate dance in a compelling way. Obviously, you can't begin to write a critique until you have seen the performance that you will review, but what else is important to know and do before and during the writing process? The rest of this chapter answers that question. Although each element of the process is presented separately here, writing is actually more holistic and intuitive than following a to-do list. As described in chapter 1, writing is a circular process that involves writing itself, reviewing your writing, contemplating your writing, and making changes, so keep this in mind as you work.

This is an excerpt from Writing About Dance.

More Excerpts From Writing About Dance



Get the latest insights with regular newsletters, plus periodic product information and special insider offers.